The department of defense dod reported on its office of management and budget circular a76 studies in july 2000. The court held that falstaff was not a potential entrant into said market by any means or way other than by said acquisition. Recently, the gao released two decisions which reiterated the importance of holding meaningful discussions that do not mislead offerors during negotiated procurements. Published decisions on recently decided protests may not yet be publicly available read more here. In loc, after excluding the contractor from the competitive range, the agency gave. According to a gao report the department of defense alone. Some textbook companies have countered this by encouraging teachers to assign homework that must be done on the publishers website. The protester also raises allegations of unequal treatment under the management and technical factors. Decision l a r e n e o l e r g t r p m o c o f t h e u ni t e d s t a t e s document for public release the decision issued on the date below was subject to a gao protective order.
Challenges by potential or unsuccessful offerors to award a contract are termed bid protests. The gao knocked down protests from harris it services corp. The rfp provided that the competitive range would include only. Tigers proposal is excluded from the competitive range because their price was unreasonably high when compared to other offerors with the same past performance rating of excellent. The court found there were two missing terms, the agreement to submit required performance and payment bonds and the period in which the bid was open for acceptance, both of which were substantive, material terms. Gao, participated in the preparation of the decision. The notice requirements for the competitive range were inapplicable. Ptsis protest of its exclusion from the competitive range challenges numerous aspects of the agencys evaluation of its proposal under the management, technical and past performance factors. Gao reminds offerors excluded from a competitive range to. Price must also be considered and not in the abstract or as part of a price reasonableness analysis. The gao had concluded these missing terms were incorporated by reference through dillards submission of an sf 30 acknowledging.
Rather, ptp challenges the agencys decision to exclude its proposal. Sep 29, 2012 weve already reported on gao decisions in which gao makes it clear that the tradeoff analysis must be made on all proposals within the competitive range. Protest challenging the protesters exclusion from the competitive range is dismissed as untimely, where the agency excluded the protesters proposal based on its high price, but the protester initially challenged the agencys technical evaluation, and did not argue that the agencys exclusion of its proposal based on price alone was unreasonable until it filed comments. Gao provides factbased, nonpartisan information to congress.
Recent gao decision permits onesided discussions as. Epa argued that the protesters exclusion from the competitive range was justified because, after analyzing the score and technical evaluation narratives, the contracting officer determined that the proposals were technically equal. Reasoned judgment required when establishing competitive range july 28, 2017 by andrew smith on may 19, 2017, the u. When combined, these two factors were more important than. A bid protest is a challenge to the terms of a solicitation or the award of a federal contract. The record clearly showed that the sseb, co and ssa did consider the proposals against all of the evaluation factors. Fema would assess whether proposed prices were reasonable, balanced, and realistic. Most sustained protests are added because we can learn from our. Ten offerors submitted proposals prior to the july 10, 2017, closing date. In order to prevail in a bid protest, a bid protest lawyer will have to show that the agencys actions were exclusion from the competitive range determination and gao bid protests technical scores. B243000 protest of air force exclusion of bid from. For the technical capabilities subfactor, offerors were to provide an. Additionally, gao does not publish most decisions dismissing a protest, including instances where an agency takes some form of corrective action.
In that decision, we sustained itos protest of the award of a contract to ahtna rdi, jv, llc. Yeah, thats a great point and its also a point about the nature of, sort of, the bleak house like conditions that can occur in bid protest world, where decisions can be made to go back to the drawing board. Although the competitive range decision is not well defined, it is one of the most important decisions in the negotiation process. Internally, they are made up of many different constituencies competing for limited. Bid protestors frequently complain that an agency improperly converted a best value procurement into a low price technically acceptable lpta procurement by awarding to the lowpriced offeror, notwithstanding the existence of higherrated. Competitive range and protest contract award process. The record here shows that the contracting officer concluded that there were only negligible or minimal differences between the vendors. This redacted version has been approved for public release. Over its nearly centurylong existence, the gao has provided an impartial forum for protesting government contract awards and terms.
Dec 12, 2017 arch systems, llc, of baltimore, maryland, and ken consulting, inc. The gao is not within the court system, which is why you cannot appeal a gao decision. If a competitive range is used, you must send preaward notifications to offerors thus excluded. Fema established a competitive range of four offerors, including both ntt and bae.
Digest where protesters proposal is found marginally acceptable, four other proposals were rated acceptable, and the agency considered price in its competitive range determination, the contracting agency reasonably excluded the protesters proposal from the competitive range. On may 10, a request for best and final offers bafos was issued to the four offerors remaining in the competitive range, and bafos were received by may 17. Administration of the federal ban on exports of unprocessed federal timber. Government contractors usually find themselves appearing before the government accountability office gao on a bid protest for one of two reasons. The gao did not view miltopes protest as a broad challenge to its elimination from the competitive range, but rather a specific allegation of either mistake or misconduct on the part of the. Bid protestors frequently complain that an agency improperly converted a best value procurement into a low price technically acceptable lpta procurement by awarding to the lowpriced offeror, notwithstanding the existence of higherrated, albeit higherpriced, proposals. Gao reports and comptroller general decisions heinonline. Agencies are not bound by initial decisions to include or exclude a proposal, and may issue successive competitive range decisions, excluding offers from the competitive range that no longer have a reasonable chance of being selected, arc professional services, inc. Further, the impact of gaos decision extends beyond the fss program to potentially all idiq contracts. Aug 11, 2016 the recent government accountability office gao decision in the cogar group, ltd. It is insufficient to pick the highest rated technical proposals and make an award to them.
Vae contends that hhs misevaluated its proposal and challenges the evaluation. Government accountability office gao protest regulations. After making a determination that the agencys competitive range determination process is flawed, you must promptly file a bid protest to preserve your rights. Furthermore, the gao and the courts want to see the actual steps the government has taken to move the challenged procurement into a competitive posture. Agencies do not have to comply with its recommendations. The decision issued on the date below was subject to a gao protective order. Oct 20, 2016 notwithstanding the fact that gao decisions actually are recommendations, agencies and departments have cancelled orders andor not exercised options as a direct result of the agencys actions. It is not clear from your post if the offerors were 1 originally excluded from the competitive range or 2 included in the competitive range, but subsequently eliminated. The purpose of holding discussions in negotiated procurements is to maximize the best value to the government. The federal acquisition regulation far competitive range procedure offers. Protest challenging the agencys evaluation of proposals is denied, where the protester challenged only three of nearly 40 weaknesses, significant weaknesses, and deficiencies, leaving gao to conclude that its proposal would not be considered acceptable even if its protest were successful. Appropriations law bid protests other decisions general legal decisions faqs red book. Pinnacle challenging its exclusion from the competitive range in nasa procurement for aircraft logistics, integration, configuration management, and engineering services.
The main steps of that process model are set forth in table 1. Mar 23, 2016 the debriefing contained debriefing slides, the source selection decision document which discussed the strengths for the proposals that were included in the competitive range, and the source evaluation boards findings. It objects, llc ito, a small business of herndon, virginia, protests the corrective action that the department of commerce, national oceanic and atmospheric administration noaa is taking in response to our recommendation in it objects, llc, b418012. More than half of the protests at gao and cofc are from self identified small. Gao bid protest procedures under the competition in contracting act. Page ii gao 09289 military temporary retirement table 12. New market entrants and substitute products are the two main competitive forces challenging the movie industry. Gao issues decisions regarding federal bid protests, appropriations law, and other legal matters. Gao reports on adp matters need a central source of gaoladp documents. The table, from gao, was added above to show the correct scoring and pricing. The processes of government procurement in the united states enable federal, state and local. Gao recently sustained another protest in which the army failed to evaluate proposals solely on the factors identified in the solicitation. Jan 21, 2016 currently, the government accountability office gao is the primary organization that provides congress with independent analysis and information on which they may base their policy decisions.
In this regard, the rfp clearly tied the decision whether to permit oral presentations to the agencys decision to establish a competitive range for the purpose of conducting discussionsa matter which is within the agencys discretion. The range determination is often a point for protests, especially with the gao. Failure to challenge multiple weaknesses and deficiencies. Thus, gao held, the bureaus evaluation of tsis proposal was unequal as compared to the evaluations of the quotations of four awardees.
However, the gao found the rfp did not reasonably advise offerors executive. The protester contends that the decision to exclude its proposal was the result of an improper evaluation. What changes have these problems caused the movie and television studios to make. After evaluating the bafos, award was made to it corporationohm on may 31 and all other offerors were so notified. While the protester argued that its protest presented examples of the agencys many alleged. In a recent bid protest decision, the gao wrote that the far precludes evaluating an offeror unfavorably because of a neutral or unknown past performance ratingand that the prohibition on unfavorable treatment prevents an agency from excluding an offeror from the competitive range on the basis of a neutral rating. Gao protest of exclusion from the competitive range. Global dynamics, llc gd, of columbia, maryland, protests the exclusion of its proposal from the competitive range under request for proposals rfp no. Gao recommended reevaluation and, if necessary, discussions and revised proposals.
Gao issues legal opinions and decisions to congress and federal agencies on the use of. Gao holds low price technically acceptable lpta award. Protest of exclusion from competitive range untimely. For most provinces, the national higher education entrance examination is held once a year in recent years some of the provinces in china hold examinations twice a year and the extra one is called the spring entrance examination. And even though the defense department doesnt classify pilferage as a major problem, its annual inventory shrinkage alone runs a billion or two a year. Number and percent of reservists receiving a disability evaluation system determination, by service, fiscal years. Recent gao decision highlights possibility of limited. Philip nacke and david ralston, the firms government contracts litigation partners who authored the guide. Accounting and auditing reforms are urgently needed and essential to any plan for recapitalizing. Each year gao issues a bibliography of documents lssued by the gao on matters related to. Must the agency reconsider its setaside decision when, after. It said investment in such systems has doubled in the. Don mansfields content page 2 the wifcon forums and blogs.
On february 11, vmd filed a gao bid protest challenging its exclusion from the competitive range. This draft legislation allows limiting the competitive range, for the purpose of conducting discussions, to at least the three highest ranked offerors. Under far part 16 task order solicitation, agency can. And the challenge can be great when an agency receives proposals from 15 or more competitors. March 3 gao decisions davison on government contract law.
It does not have the standing of a court, a board of contract appeals, or, for example, the sba office of hearings and appeals. Those decisions can be challenged, and you can have an initial bid protest morph into litigation that may go on for years. Protest of exclusion from competitive range untimely after. The previous schedule before 2003 of the national higher education entrance examination was in july every year. Us gao decision warvel products inc 1999 prison legal news. Even offerors eliminated before the competitive range may have protest standing. Agencys conduct of discussions with offerors in competitive range. Government accountability office gao sustained a protest filed by pinnacle solutions, inc. Government procurement in the united states wikipedia. Regardless, offerors excluded or otherwise eliminated from the competitive range may request a debriefing see 15. A protester may also choose to withdraw their protest prior to a decision being reached. Guide to federal procurement protests govcon network.
An agency entering into discussions must provide meaningful discussions see gao decisions on this issue. Mirroring the reasoning in caddell, gao concluded that under the unique circumstances, only sevenson suffered from the procurement error, and so onesided discussions were appropriate to place sevenson in the same competitive position that the other offerors, including ecc, were in following their receipt of meaningful discussions. If a competitive range is used, you must send preaward notifications to. Beginning with page 6, the guide is set up so that opposite each instruction page are sample sections of executive summaries. Just disagreeing with the agency will get the protest thrown out. The federal acquisition regulation far competitive range. Are gao tests for competitive range determinations still.
The agency reasonably included in the competitive range proposals that. A reference list of evaluation books and articles november 1. Client alert public practices pillsbury winthrop shaw pittman llp. The decision to eliminate any offeror through this procedure will not constitute the establishment of a competitive range, as described in far 15. The recent government accountability office gao decision in l3 unidyne, inc. Mar 23, 2006 development prematurely in 2003, the government. All offerors in the competitive range submitted revised.
Do not use competitive ranges to exclude offersproposals unless solicitation stated discussions were going to be used. W81k0412r0025, issued by the department of the army for registered nursing services for the san antonio military healthcare system. The gao presumes the listed factors are equal if the rfp does not state their. The court of federal claims decisions were added a few years later with appeals from the court of appeals for the federal circuit added a little after that. Bid protest decisions listed by federal acquisition regulation. Based on this evaluation, gao determined that eliminating ntt from the competitive range was reasonable. Gaos attempt to bootstrap missing bid terms falls short.
Competitive range determination in government contracting. The gao wants to support congress, while at the same time doing right by the citizens of the united states. Agency has discretion, not obligation, to engage in. In this decision, the gao found that the agencys statements made it reasonably clear that what the agency regarded as a weakness was the protesters failure to furnish an explanation for the change in approach to. Gao holds low price technically acceptable lpta award improper under best value procurement. Until 2004, the government investigative and auditing agency was known as the general accounting office. They audit, investigate, perform analyses, issue legal decisions and report anything that the government is. Competitive foods have been a controversial issue for more than 35 years. Weaknesses cannot be assigned unequally, gao confirms. Government contracts are governed by federal common law, a body of law. The government accountability office gao was created by congress in 1921. This decision reinforces that gao will sustain a protest based on unequal evaluation of weaknesses. How corporations conquered america and ruined our health the corporate class has accumulated a staggering level of power in washington and weve all paid the. The more proposals included in the competitive range, the more information.
Gao protest case studies dod small business programs. Gao sustained the protest based on the unequal evaluation and recommended reevaluation of proposals. For the decision to be considered reasonable, the contracting officer. Gao s html and pdf decisions transposed psis and skyhawks prices.
The watchblog offers short, shareable insights from gao reports on a wide variety of topics. Students with a new textbook can use the pass code in the book to register on the site. Initial protest failed to challenge actual reason for. Individuals may ob tain a copy by contacting author ulrike richardson on 202 2753948. Jul 23, 20 the comptroller general of the united states is the leader of the gao, and is appointed to a 15year term by the u. Protest arguing that the agency was required to seek clarifications before excluding a proposal from the competitive range is denied, where such communications are discretionary unless the offerors past performance is the determining factor for a decision to include or exclude a proposal from the competitive range. In a precedentsetting decision in harris it services corp. Any further guidance issued by omb should acknowledge the priorities that exist in the far and explain how contracting officers are to proceed.
This months roundup discusses three noteworthy decisions from the government accountability office gao covering timeliness, premature claims, and. Key case law rules for government contract formationnook book. Olympus challenged the evaluation of its proposal in a protest to our office. Aug 26, 2014 questions and answerswhat competitive forces have challenged the movie industry. With regard to tiger specifically, the competitive range determination stated. Offerors were informed that the technical evaluation factors combined were significantly more important than price. Protest of exclusion from competitive range untimely after award. The gao and the courts find ex post facto explanations usually asserted for the first time in heat of protest litigation to be less persuasive. The organizational structure of the schools is an important consideration in formulating recommendations for standards for competitive foods and beverages in schools.
508 1473 99 286 439 1476 257 491 260 529 745 209 1474 1070 339 256 849 613 426 1030 153 312 1371 512 882 1005 299 766 1142 523 1264 911 771 501 872